| 2009 | Renee Anders |
| 2010 | Cathy Eatmon |
| 2011 | Anne Moorman-Smith |
| 2012 | Lisa Packer |
| 2013 | Jana Winders |
| 2014 | Susan Jarett |
| 2015 | Kathryn Johnson |
| 2016 | Angela Magnum |
| 2017 | Beth Ulffers |
| 2018 | Sandra Teglas |
| 2019 | Dawn Wilson |
| 2020 | Nicole Lawson |
| 2021 | Pamela Day |
| 2022 | Lindsay Williams |
| 2023 | Laura Black |
| 2024 | Zadda Bazzy |
| 2025 | Jeannine DuMond |